MADISON, Wis. (CN) - Ob tsev neeg lub npe hauv npias tau sib cav ua ntej tsoomfwv tus kws txiav txim plaub hnub Thursday dhau los ntawm kev tshaj tawm thiab muaj peev xwm ntawm kev kub ntxhov ntawm Bud Light tshaj tawm thov Miller Lite thiab Coors Lub teeb muaj lub siab-fructose pob kws phoov.

MillerCoors foob nws kev sib foob thaum Lub Peb Hlis, hais tias qhov kev tshaj tawm uas tau tsim los ntawm tus neeg sib tw nrog Anheuser-Busch yuam kev cov neeg tau txais kev ntseeg tias Miller Lite thiab Coors Teeb, ob ntawm MillerCoors 'cov khoom lag luam, muaj cov khoom qab zib hauv kev sim ua kom tsis raug mob MillerCoors cov khoom lag luam hauv khw muag npias uas muaj neeg coob thiab nce kev muag khoom ntawm Anheuser-Busch's Bud Light.

Rooj plaub no, coj los ntawm US District Judge William Conley hauv Madison, Wisconsin, iab liam tias kev tshaj tawm txog lab-daus las, uas muaj cov paib tshaj tawm, thiab cov tshaj tawm TV tshaj tawm nyob rau xyoo no Super Bowl thiab Academy Awards, yog ua rau lub hom phiaj ua kom cov neeg siv dag zog txij li MillerCoors. tsis siv cov roj ntsha uas muaj roj ntau hauv cov pob kws, muaj cov khoom qab zib nyob hauv ntau pua cov khoom lag luam uas tab tom nce mus rau kev rog, kab mob plawv thiab colorectal cancer.

Hloov chaw, MillerCoors hais tias nws siv cov khoom sib txawv heev - cov kua pob kws dawb - hauv nws cov txheej txheem fermentation, uas tau tag nrho cov poov xab thiab vim li ntawd tsis tuaj yeem ua rau haus kawg. Lub tuam txhab thov kom muaj kev pab tiv thaiv kev tsis ncaj ncees raws li Txoj Cai Lanham ua ke nrog kev tshaj tawm, qee qhov tau raug txiav tawm.

Donald Schott, cov lus ntuas rau MillerCoors los ntawm Madison cov ceg ntawm lub tuam txhab thoob tebchaws Quarles & Brady, tau sib cav rau hnub Thursday tias kev tshaj tawm ua si tawm ntawm qhov kev xav ua ntej uas cov neeg siv khoom tsis nyiam pob kws phoov, ntshai nws qhov tsis zoo thiab tsis xav kom nws haus, yog li ua rau MillerCoors los ntawm implying tias Miller Lite thiab Coors Teeb muaj nws.

Tus kws txiav txim plaub ntug Conley tau taw tes ceev hais tias "yog tias qhov no yog hais txog qhov txhob txwm ua, koj yeej yuav yeej," tab sis kev tiv thaiv tawm tsam cov lus foob hauv Seventh Circuit precedent yuav tsis muaj pov thawj txaus rau rooj plaub kom muaj sia nyob nrog cov ua tau zoo.

MillerCoors lees paub tias nws siv cov pob kws cov kua qaub uas tau ua tiav rau qee qhov ntawm cov txheej txheem brewing tab sis hais tias nws yog qhov cuav kom hais tias cov khoom tiav npias muaj cov pob kws phoov.

Thaj chaw grey ntawm kev tshaj tawm uas nrhiav kev ua kom zoo tshaj qhov ua rau muaj kev nkag siab yuam kev, ua kom cov neeg siv khoom lag luam ua lub hauv paus kom hloov cov khoom lag luam, thiab piv cov khoom xyaw thiab cov txheej txheem ntawm cov khoom tau sib tham ntawm lub sijhawm ntev hnub Thursday kev sib cav.

Conley tau nug cov lus nug thaum ntxov ntawm seb "qhov ua rau raug kev nkag siab tsis txaus siab" yog nws tus kheej ua txhaum Txoj Cai Lanham.

Schott tau hais tias "cov lus tseeb uas ua rau pom kev tsis tseeb yog qhov ua tau raws li Txoj Cai Lanham," mus hais tias "koj tsis tas yuav hais qhov tsis zoo txhawm rau kom ua rau qhov kev xav tsis zoo."

Tus kws txiav txim plaub tau xav tias nws tau txaus rau kev pab "tsis muaj qee qhov tsis txaus ntseeg" rau Anheuser-Busch los qhia txog qee yam uas yog qhov ua tau raug cai - tias MillerCoors siv pob kws phoov thiab Anheuser-Busch tsis - nyob rau hauv txoj kev uas yuav txhob txwm dag ntxias cov neeg siv khoom, lossis ntawm tsawg kawg yog tsis kho qhov kev ua yuam kev uas twb muaj lawm.

James Bennett, tus kws lij choj nrog St. Louis cov tuam txhab Dowd Bennett sawv cev rau Anheuser-Busch, tsis xav li ntawd, xav tias nws "tsuas yog cov lus tseeb uas muaj tseeb" tias cov kua phoov yog cov npe nyob hauv Miller Lite thiab Coors Light.

Bennett tau hais tias kev tshaj tawm "tsuas yog xav taw qhia qhov txawv ntawm cov khoom xyaw ntau dua" hauv Aheuser-Busch cov khoom lag luam piv rau MillerCoors 'npias.

Conley puas tau zam nrog ib daim paib siv rau hauv qhov kev tshaj tawm ad uas tau hais tias Bud Light muaj "100% tsawg dua pob kws phoov" tshaj li MillerCoors cov khoom lag luam, hu nws "yuam kev hauv qhov huab."

Tus kws tu plaub tau hais tias "Nws yuav zoo li hais tias muaj 1,000% tsawg dua radon," hauv cov khoom lag luam, tus kws hais plaub tau hais.

Bennett tau sau tseg tias daim paib thiab lwm yam zoo li nws tau raug txiav tawm thiab muab pov tseg, lossis tsawg kawg yog nyob rau hauv cov txheej txheem ntawm kev coj ua.

Tab sis Bennett tau thim rov qab Anheuser-Busch lub tswv yim tsuas yog siv cov lus siv uas MillerCoors nws tus kheej siv xws li "brewed nrog," "ua nrog," thiab "siv," thiab hais tias lub suab nrov ntawm lub phiaj xwm tsis muaj qhov tsis zoo kiag li cov lus lossis tsis yog-lus.

Schott opined thaum lub sijhawm nws rov tawm tsam hais tias "lub koob npe nrov hauv kev puas tsuaj [MillerCoors] tau pom yog lub ntsiab lus ntawm kev sib raug zoo tsis muaj kev cuam tshuam," hais txog cov kev tshawb fawb ntawm cov neeg muag khoom tsis ntev los no.

Ob lub Bennett thiab Conley tau nug cov tshuaj thiab cov qauv coj los sib piv, txawm li cas los xij, nrog Bennett taw rau cov khoom siv sib txawv thiab hais tias MillerCoors tau hais qhia qhov muag nce ntxiv thiab kev ua lag luam sib koom txij li lub phiaj xwm ad pib.

Conley qhia thaum kaw cov lus sib cav hnub Thursday tias nws cia siab tias yuav tshaj tawm nws qhov kev txiav txim siab qee lub lim tiam tom ntej.